Category Archives: Blog Posts

Quick Mugshot Gripe

Just wrapped up a 304-comment-long conversation over on Mugshot that occurred over the last few hours.

Of course, I can’t link to it from here (gripe #1), and even if I could, no one will ever be able to see the majority of the conversation (gripe #2), since you can only get to the last bunch. I don’t know what the exact count is they show, but if it’s around 50, that means 83% of it is essentially lost, except for in the minds of the three of us who were there.

And yes, I know it’s probably stretching / exceeding the bounds of what that comment (”quips” actually) system was intended for, but it still kind of stinks.

Happy Anniversary


Starting a Journey

Track is Back

Over on identi.ca, that is.

Some of you may remember me mentioning the incredible utility of a service that used to be offered by Twitter called “track”. The short summary is that it basically allowed sent you (in real time, via a chat interface) “tweets” containing keywords that you were interested in hearing about. This opened up all sorts of possibilities for real-time search and conversation discovery, adding tremendous value to the large pool of data flowing through the system by making it available to everyone regardless of any “follow” relationship.

A while back, Twitter disabled this feature as a part of an effort to stop their servers from crashing all the time. As they recovered and re-engineered, they gradually re-enabled some of the features that they had turned off, but this particular one never really came back.

The need was partially fulfilled by Summize (which was eventually acquired by Twitter and became Twitter Search), but it was missing the interface that made track so addictive and useful, so TwitterSpy stepped in and bridged that particular gap.

Now it appears that @dustin has put together an XMPP gateway into the identi.ca network to meet the same needs, only this time hooked into what appears to be the more robust, built-for-scaling backbone of identi.ca.

In addition, this service also has the (not yet public) ability to post between systems as well (Twitter and identi.ca, specifically), potentially offering a bridge between worlds that is very promising.

I’m trying to steer clear a bit from too many technical details of what that all means, so here’s the simple run down on how to start using track in identi.ca

Assuming you have an identi.ca account and have enabled IM access for it (see the identi.ca site for instructions on this part), add laconica@west.spy.net to your buddy list in your Jabber chat client (GTalk, Pidgin, etc.).

I was going to create a numbered list of instructions, but it’s so simple that that’s the only step. Message this user with “help” to see a list of commands and get started tracking!

identi.ca

Yes, I obviously have yet to learn this lesson, so I went ahead and signed up for another social media service. Here I am on identi.ca

In case you haven’t heard of identi.ca, the short summary is that it’s Twitter done right.

Everything Twitter currently does is provided by identi.ca, plus some. These additions are particularly interesting to me, since they primarily revolve around openness.

  1. You get OpenID support for starters, which you can associate with and use to log in to multiple accounts (if for some reason you’d want more than one).
  2. Free - as in no, reallyfree - The software itself is truly free software; the main identi.ca server that most people will sign up on and use runs an unmodified copy of the source that’s available for everyone to download and use on their own servers. Leaving no stone unturned, even the data published to their servers is licensed under Creative Commons.
  3. Federation - Here’s the kicker, the one that sent me over the edge. If you do choose to take advantage of the freedom listed above and set up your own server, your server can participate in the larger network, extending it rather than becoming yet another alternative or competitor (unless you want to do that).
    You can even start out on their servers and move your account to your own server(s) later, and keep on participating in the network you have helped to build. I don’t think I’m overstating things when I say that this aspect is revolutionary in the new world of social media.

At this point the only advantage Twitter has in its favor is its user base. Now, considering the nature of these services and the value they provide, this is admittedly a huge advantage.

However, it is my hope is that in time the benefits inherent in the identi.ca approach and the game-changing opportunities for innovation without fragmentation that it provides will win over users (and / or bridge to and from Twitter itself) in the end.

Here we go again

Dark Knight Review

I thought the movie was great.

I think watching it at the tail end of spending a week in the big city may have enhanced the experience a bit, but I’m positive that seeing it on in IMAX definitely did. I was surprised to learn (right before it started) that a good chunk of the movie (around 30 minutes) was actually filmed in IMAX, so it wasn’t just the normal movie on a bigger screen.

Ledger as the Joker was as good as everyone has been raving about; such a shame that we won’t see him again at some point. I really hope they don’t try to bring back the character with a different actor, unless it’s very far into the future, perhaps as a demented long-time resident in Arkham assylum.

The big box office virtually guarantees there will be more follow-ups; hopefully they keep the same creative team on, as it’s working very well. I’d love to eventually see an adaptation of what I consider to be the best Batman story: The Dark Knight Returns. Of course, they’d have to make it an alternate universe kind of thing relative to the continuity of this movie, and they’d have to be sure to get the effects right for the Superman parts, but I think it would fit well into a movie.

That’s about it for the spoiler-free section of this review.

– SPOILERS BELOW –

Read More »

Free Cookies From Starbucks

The fine folks at Starbucks just gave me a big box of cookies that they can’t sell anymore since they expire today. Of course, I currently have nowhere to store them, so the next person on the street who asks me for money or food is going to get more than they bargained for!

Politics Talk

Well, I’ve managed to successfully avoid getting into conversations about politics online for quite a while now, and have found it quite refreshing. I’ve also steered clear of them in person for the most part, with some brief exceptions.

One of the exceptions occurred tonight, and while (I felt) it was civil and respectful all around, it did serve as a gentle reminder of why I have decided to avoid them as a general rule.

The main reason is that they are rarely beneficial to anyone involved. I don’t know if that’s due to a failure in my ability to communicate, a lack of open-mindedness of one or more parties involved (including myself), just the nature of the subject, or all of the above.

When it comes to politics, there are a variety of complex issues that go into the decision to vote for a particular candidate (for example). Unfortunately, (in my experience at least) conversations about politics are usually not held around the broad base of that information, but focused on individual issues that are likely to be controversial and / or easy to attack.

It might be interesting to explore approaching these conversations with the angle of finding the things that we agree on, but I’m not exactly sure how that might go either. In the end I think it might be best just to acknowledge the differences and focus on things that are either more important or less divisive (or even both).

I think it would also be wise to keep in mind that (in contrast to the way political media likes to line things up), people often don’t agree on every single issue with the particular party or candidate that they are backing, and probably shouldn’t. If we find ourselves in such a position of unwavering allegiance, I’d suggest it’s probably time to question our own filters that we may have placed on our understanding and ability to look at things from multiple points of view.

For you guys who were involved in the conversation tonight, (since most of you will probably read this), I would clarify that my desire to refrain from these conversations shouldn’t reflect negatively on you or on my opinions of your views or how you presented them. I think it’s safe to say that we respect each other’s intelligence, that we realize that different people have different theories on (among other things) how government should work, and that it’s OK to disagree about them.

Personally, I’d just prefer to not get into it in the future and focus on other subjects that would either be more beneficial or at least more entertaining. Life is too short to waste it arguing. While the history of the comments here on this blog (at least as it was in the past) stands as evidence that I haven’t always heeded that advice, I hope to change that going forward as much as I possibly can.

I Don’t Recommend FriendFeed

The other day I recommended FriendFeed as an alternative to Mugshot for link sharing. Today I withdraw that recommendation.

It was clearly a mistake for me to recommend the service since I had never actually used it myself; I was only going off of the recommendations of others.

I was under the mistaken impression that it would offer the same features as the solution I’m using now (here on my blog), but it does not. It also suffers from some of the same issues that I complained about with Pownce and Mugshot.

In particular, here is my main gripe:
No ability to subscribe to a feed (or any other notification, as far as I can tell) of comments on previously posted items. This appears to include items posted directly in an individual’s feed as well as items posted in a “room”, etc.

Until this feature exists, FriendFeed is suffering from the same issues I have with Pownce - namely that it requires me to hit their site/app directly in order to check for updates in conversations. At least it’s a step ahead of Mugshot in that there are feeds for the initial items/links, but it’s still lacking the ability to track the follow-ups.

Also, while I do now have a FriendFeed account, I do not plan to add all my other stuff into it, for one simple reason (directly related to the above issue): you can’t follow the comment conversations. Therefore, I’d rather people not comment on my stuff there, since FriendFeed makes it difficult / inconvenient (for me and others) to follow. I would much rather do that here on my blog, where comment subscriptions are available on both a site wide or individual item basis. This is exactly what I want, and FriendFeed does not offer it.

Of course, I may have missed something. Anyone out there who knows otherwise, please let me know by commenting here.

Is Mugshot Dead?

In case you’re not familiar with Mugshot, see my previous posts about it: Initial review, Follow-up.

I’m starting to wonder whether this project has been abandoned. I haven’t seen much progress recently, and their blog and developer wiki both seem to be very rarely updated.

I got to wondering about this today, as I tried to load a linked article and it took three tries (after one timeout and one server error) in order to get the link (which routes through their server) to even open the article. Of course, that only served to remind me how frustrated I am with this app / service.

My number one gripe remains that a large portion of the content is not accessible (via services, feeds, or notifications - or anything for that matter) outside of their client application or via a browser directly on their site. In this day and age, I don’t think that’s acceptable for a social networking app.

Since this blog is the #1 Google search result for “mugshot review” (which in itself is probably another bad sign), I have a glimmer of hope that someone - anyone - involved with the project might take notice and at least comment to say that the project is still alive. As a bonus, they could also address my concerns above.

Like I mentioned last time, if it weren’t for some of you who actually use it to share links, I would have dropped Mugshot a long time ago. Perhaps I need to begin my campaign to get you guys to switch to something else. :-)

Fatherhood

A must watch video on fatherhood and personal / family responsibility in general.

Please check it out even if you’re not an Obama fan; I think anyone would appreciate and agree with most of it - politics aside (there is a bit of political policy pushing towards the end, but I’m sure you can stomach it) There is also a very clear and direct faith reference at the very end, in case that might bother you (or encourage you).

He even throws in a humorous diss about 8th grade graduations - excellent.